☀ New York | Tuesday November 17, 2026 | Sign In
⚡ TRENDING NOW

Government reforms to zero-hours contracts raise concerns

NHS hospital and care workers.
NHS hospital and care workers.

The government faces warnings from major employment bodies that proposed reforms to zero-hours contracts could create significant unintended consequences for the NHS, social care, and fire services. Health leaders and local government representatives have submitted responses to the consultation, arguing that the measures could increase costs and reduce workforce flexibility.

Costs and staffing concerns for the NHS

Analysis by NHS Employers suggests that NHS organisations in England might need to hire more than 800 additional administrative staff and around 610 managers to comply with the new rules. The projected cost of this increased bureaucracy could reach £900 million annually.

Employers argue that the NHS “bank” system provides genuine two-way flexibility. Around 85% of bank workers hold a substantive contract and choose to work extra shifts. Among those without a substantive contract, a survey shows that 74% report they can find the shifts and hours they want through these arrangements.

Ben Morrin, chief executive of NHS Employers, stated that the current proposals risk reducing the flexibility that many bank workers value. He noted that the plans could increase bureaucracy and generate substantial unbudgeted costs at a time when the NHS is focused on improving productivity. Morrin argued that the proposals do not adequately reflect the operational realities of delivering healthcare services 24 hours a day, seven days a week.

These staffing challenges stem from the government’s desire to introduce guaranteed hours, where the offered hours reflect hours worked over a 12-week reference period. The consultation also covers reasonable notice of shifts and payment for shifts cancelled at short notice.

The HR body is calling for the reference period to be 52 weeks instead of 12.

The Local Government Association (LGA) has also raised concerns. It warns that on-call firefighters, who provide cover in rural areas and make up more than 90% of the country’s coverage, should be excluded from the reforms. The LGA argues that including these workers would be “unworkable” and would result in significant costs to fire services.

While the government is committed to tackling the one-sided flexibility of zero-hours contracts, it is currently analysing responses before laying regulations expected to come into force later in 2027.

Flexibility in social care and adult social care

The LGA highlighted distinct structural challenges within adult social care. Social care differs, as flexibility is driven by fluctuating and unpredictable care needs. The LGA advised the government to consider sector-specific flexibilities for this area. This could include longer reference periods and exemptions for exceptional circumstances.

Government response and future timeline

A government spokesperson stated the commitment to tackling one-sided flexibility. The spokesperson noted that workers often bear the financial risk of uncertain hours. The government expressed gratitude for responses to the summer consultation. Officials are taking these views into account to ensure new rights work in the real world.

Rob Moss, a business journalist with over 25 years of experience, has been editor of Personnel Today since 2010. He specialises in labour market economics, gender diversity and family-friendly working. Moss has hosted hundreds of webinars and podcasts. Before writing about HR and employment, Moss ran news and feature desks on publications serving the global optical and eyewear market. He also served the UK electrical industry and energy markets in Asia and the Middle East. Moss is the author of this article.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *